|
Post by cram on Apr 16, 2006 1:01:50 GMT -5
dude you got no chance,
1) you don't animate 2) the tourney's allready started, and 3) you can't animate
|
|
|
Post by legendsofthering on Apr 22, 2006 12:52:08 GMT -5
Are you guys done?
|
|
|
Post by [sic] on Apr 22, 2006 20:03:48 GMT -5
we still got one day. well actually i'm not done with what i was going to turn in so i might have to whip p something else. either way i will have something in.
|
|
Rogan
Been Around
An Epic of Wasted Days
Posts: 178
|
Post by Rogan on Apr 23, 2006 3:27:01 GMT -5
but thats what you said last week
|
|
mwhittle
Newbie World Order Member
Posts: 52
|
Post by mwhittle on Apr 23, 2006 18:31:55 GMT -5
you are such a faggot its not even funny
|
|
|
Post by Big Sexy on Apr 24, 2006 2:15:58 GMT -5
Oiy, I'm So friggin' close, but it's 1:15 and I gotta be up at 8....I'll be done tomorrow for sure, sorry guys.
|
|
|
Post by Big Sexy on Apr 24, 2006 20:18:17 GMT -5
It's done.
|
|
|
Post by legendsofthering on Apr 25, 2006 14:35:42 GMT -5
JUDGE AWAY JUDGES!
|
|
|
Post by [sic] on Apr 25, 2006 17:56:48 GMT -5
i forgot to put them in this thread, i know it doesnt matter but whatever...
|
|
|
Post by cram on Apr 25, 2006 18:26:21 GMT -5
ah nice...i'll do the judgings tomorrow if possible... i've got school in about 45 minutes and then i'm going to the pub tonight so i'll get it done tomorrow after school.
|
|
|
Post by Kami on Apr 25, 2006 19:32:23 GMT -5
My judgings will be in tomorrow as well.
But, right now, I must say, that you two did a great job, and this is easily the hardest judging I've ever done.
But yes, final scores tomorrow!
|
|
doug
Newbie World Order Member
I r [legendary]
Posts: 23
|
Post by doug on Apr 26, 2006 9:46:43 GMT -5
both entries are really good, if I had to choose one, just based on first impressions, I'd have to go with big sexy's because of his osaka street cutter spot, and the chair shot spot. I just happen to like those parts a lot.
|
|
|
Post by cram on Apr 27, 2006 5:46:44 GMT -5
CRAM'S JUDGINGS
Again, I'll run through my crazy method of judging animations.
Basics - Positioning, Colour problems, Keeping everyone in frame moving, realism etc.
Stipulation - How well you've done with the Stipulations given.
Flow - How the animation all flows together, this also includes smoothness of the animation and how transitions
from one move to another are made
Difficulty - The skill that the animation would've taken to put together
Also I'm a pessimist so you both start at a perfect score and I take marks off for the mistakes and problems I see
-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
Big Sexy
NOTE - I've broken the moves up into moves for my judging ease, i will also refer to the frames as they are in
separate moves
Basics
SHORT ARM CLOTHESLINE - Frame 11 you should've positioned the sprites by Rogan's Left Foot because that's in the same position as the frame before - An impact on frame 20 would've gone down a treat because the bounce looks a little weird afterwords
OSAKA STREET CUTTER - Frame rate on the suplex is a tad slow
HANDSPRING SPLASH - Frame 13 is in the wrong position completely, it looks weird from frame 12 and also your CAW goes straight down on frame 14 so it takes away some momentum of the move
FIRE TABLE DOUBLE TEAM - Ram0n's CAW should've taken off on the jump at frame 7, not frame 6.
SCORE - 20/25
Stipulation - Well there wasn't a stip so you both get perfect 25 scores for this part
SCORE - 25/25
Flow - I Must say the first move looks Brutal with the customized sell - The sell by both men on the second move looks weird because they're both doing the same thing practically - As mentioned before, the positioning error on frame 13 of the handspring splash takes away from the momentum
SCORE - 21/25
Difficulty - Between the fact that you did 5 moves, the fire, the Chair shot and the edited Table (burnt effect) and Ladder (different angle) you get a near perfect score for this category, but not perfect because some of the moves are pretty simple
SCORE - 23/25
TOTAL SCORE - 89/100 = 89%
-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-
[sic]
Basics
LADDER SAULT - Frame 14 doesn't really need to be there as your CAW moves backward in frame 13 and 15, but forwards in 14. It looks pretty Jerky - Frames 18, 19 and 20 your CAW is in the same position. Some movement is better than no Movement. - 23-24 positioning error on your CAW's feet - The Arch of the Moonsault goes very much down until frame 29 and on frame 30 it just jumps forwards allot more.
GERMAN DROPKICK - Frame 11 your CAW didn't need to move, again, just looks jerky - Frame 28 Maul's Faint Interest bounces up-wards off the Table a little when he should've fallen downward to break it - Your CAW's breathing at the start is too fast, you should repeat the frames at the top and the bottom of the breath a second time to get it looking schmick.
SCORE - 19/25
Stipulation - Well there wasn't a stip so you both get perfect 25 scores for this part
SCORE - 25/25
Flow -
LADDER SAULT - the Transition from standing on the Ladder is pretty well done, but it still looks a little off - The moonsault problem i mentioned earlier puts me off this animation quite a bit. It just throws out the whole animation because it's glaring at me every time i watch it.
GERMAN DROPKICK - 18-21, DFS' feet go all whack and it looks bad when watching it at speed - The animation has a rushed feel to it. the Dropkick comes off as clustered (i know you were going for your CAW lifting him up a little, but it didn't come out as well as it could've) and it's just action from start to finish for that animation, a few frames here and there to slow it down a little would've helped this out allot.
SCORE - 20/25
Difficulty - Neither move looks overly difficult to pull off, but the big falls in both animations are hard to do (i would know, I'm trying something big at the moment too) so bonus marks for that. It just has a really old skool animation feel, as BS's animations do too, but because you did 2 moves where he did 5, BS Gets a better score in this category
SCORE - 20/25
TOTAL SCORE - 84/100 = 84%
FINAL STANDINGS BS - 89% [sic] - 84%
Congrats to BS and a good showing by both competitors in this Final Round.
|
|
|
Post by Giant Killer on Apr 28, 2006 1:14:33 GMT -5
First off, I really liked both animations. There wasn't much of a stip and I think we all almost lost interst half way through this tournament. Even this being so I think these two animations are very well done and you both deserved to be in the finals.
[sic] The reverse powbomb, dropkick, german was awesome. Your the king of the big fall animations and you came through here. The flip after the german is awesome and the falls through the table are also really good. The way the table breaks for Maul is cool because it seems like he gets more of the force as he is the one getting the move done to. Also the frames you added in of the one taunt as Maul is being lifted up really makes this part of the animation.
The second part has it's flaws however. Your CAW is in the same position for 4 frames and it seems off. It looks cool when your CAW jumps off just as the other guy dropkicks the ladder.
Overall Score - 89%
Big Sexy[/b] You really put out a good effort after some difficulties here. I'm loving the sell on the clothesline but as Cram said I think the lack of impact hurts this part. The Osaka Street Cutter is AWESOME. The impact seems a little off to me but otherwise a good job done. In the handspring splash there is one frame that is off and really takes away from the animation. I think if that frame was in the place the splash would be able to have more height and more impact, making this part of the animaiton better.
The last two part are what really make this animation. The chair shot is flawless. You did an even better job on this one than your last one, if thats possible. I just don't see how a chair shot can be done any better. And finally the last part of the animation. The flames are perfect on the table. They look like they came straight out of Fire Pro. The Acid moonsault seems a bit off to me but the impact through the table and the burnt shit on the table afterwards really makes this part worth while!
Overall Score - 92%
My winner is:
Big Sexy
|
|
|
Post by Big Sexy on Apr 28, 2006 1:22:45 GMT -5
Now we wait for YHW to return from the dead...(only to return shortly after posting judging results)
|
|